Seattle's Best Shakes [Updated 2025]

From classic favorites to unique flavor combinations, I've sampled a diverse array of shakes across the city, ensuring only the very best make the cut.

In my quest, I reviewed a total of 12 milkshake spots, each offering their own twist on this beloved treat.

Seattle's café culture thrives on innovation, and it’s reflected in the shake offerings, pushing the boundaries of what you might expect.

Join me as we explore the top contenders, celebrating creamy textures and bold flavors that keep us coming back for more!

Shug's Soda Fountain and Ice Cream

Highlights
Classic ice cream parlor charm
S'more sundae with toasted marshmallow
Refreshing champagne float
Friendly and efficient service
Indoor and outdoor seating

Shug's Soda Fountain and Ice Cream is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Seattle, where nostalgia meets indulgence. Walking in, you’re instantly transported to a classic ice cream parlor, with its charming decor and vibrant ambiance beckoning you to enjoy a sweet escape.

I couldn’t resist trying their signature shake, and let me tell you, it was sheer bliss! The combination of rich, creamy ice cream was expertly blended to perfection—thick enough to hold its shape yet smooth enough to glide down with every sip. To elevate the experience, I opted for a playful twist: the S'more sundae, complete with toasted marshmallow that filled the air with an irresistible aroma.

As I savored each delightful spoonful, I appreciated the friendly and efficient service, which only added to the overall experience. The option for both indoor and outdoor seating allowed me to soak up the Seattle vibe while I indulged. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Shug's is a must-visit for anyone seeking a fun, classic shake experience in the city. Trust me, you won't want to miss it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Tacoma.

Frankie & Jo's Capitol Hill

Highlights
Unique vegan flavor offerings
Courteous and patient staff
Delicious waffle cones
Great ambiance and vibes
Highly recommended cheesecake

Frankie & Jo's Capitol Hill has earned its place as a must-visit spot for shake lovers in Seattle. From the moment I stepped into the vibrant space, I was greeted by a plethora of unique vegan flavor offerings that instantly piqued my interest. Choosing just one was a delightful challenge!

I decided to try the rich Salted Caramel shake, and let me tell you — it was a decadent dream. The creamy texture paired beautifully with the subtle saltiness, crafting a perfect balance of flavors. As I savored each sip, I couldn't help but appreciate the courteous and patient staff who were happy to guide me through the menu. Their recommendations were spot on!

To top off my experience, I couldn’t resist grabbing a delicious waffle cone filled with their dreamy shakes. The ambiance was lively yet cozy, making it an ideal spot for a casual outing or a sweet escape. I can easily see why this place is highly recommended — it's a true delight! If you find yourself in Capitol Hill, do not miss out on experiencing the magic of Frankie & Jo's shakes. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Seattle.

Shake Shack South Lake Union

Highlights
Mediocre burgers
Soggy cheese bacon fries
Incorrect order experience
Poor cheese quantity
Unresponsive customer service

Shake Shack South Lake Union had the potential to be an enjoyable stop on my quest for the best shakes in Seattle, but alas, my experience was a bit of a shake-up. As I approached the vibrant eatery, I was excited about the famed Shack Shake, known for its rich flavor. However, to my surprise, the star of the evening was overshadowed by an assortment of disappointing sides.

The burgers, while seemingly popular, were merely mediocre at best. I also found the soggy cheese bacon fries an unfortunate companion to my shake, lacking the crispness I had anticipated. Unfortunately, my order arrived incorrectly, which added to the frustration, and the poor cheese quantity on my fries left a lot to be desired.

The cherry on top of this experience was the unresponsive customer service that failed to alleviate my woes. In a bustling food scene like Seattle, I expected a bit more finesse, especially when it comes to a beloved treat like a milkshake. While the shake itself was serviceable, the overall experience didn’t quite deliver the joy I seek in a stellar shake outing. Perhaps next time, I’ll stick to shaking things up elsewhere.

You might also want to check out the best new york style pizza in Seattle.

Salt & Straw

Highlights
Unique and seasonal flavors
Exceptional customer service
Friendly and knowledgeable staff
Intriguing flavor combinations
Multiple locations available

When it comes to indulgent shakes, Salt & Straw in Seattle is a must-visit! Right from the moment I stepped in, the friendly and knowledgeable staff greeted me with infectious enthusiasm. The atmosphere buzzed as fellow shake enthusiasts browsed an array of uniquely crafted flavors that felt positively artistic.

Now, what truly sets Salt & Straw apart is their rotating selection of seasonal flavors. I had the delightful opportunity to try a shake made with their creamy Strawberry Honey Balsamic. The combination was nothing short of mind-blowing—sweet, tangy, and utterly refreshing. Each sip felt like a celebration of summer, even on a brisk Seattle day!

In addition to the intriguing flavor combinations, the customer service was exceptional, making the experience all the more enjoyable. The staff loves sharing their passion for ice cream, guiding indecisive customers like myself through their spectacular offerings. With multiple locations around Seattle, there's truly no excuse to miss out on this gem.

If you’re on the hunt for a shake that tantalizes the taste buds and leaves you smiling, Salt & Straw is worth every bit of the visit. 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Seattle.

Dick's Drive-In

Highlights
Old-school drive-in vibe
Delicious burgers and fries
Long lines, good food
Committed customer service
Perfect for late-night cravings

Dick's Drive-In has long been a cherished Seattle establishment, and stepping into this iconic drive-in felt like a delicious plunge into nostalgia. The old-school vibe exudes charm, pairing perfectly with the mouthwatering offerings on their menu. As I navigated the bustling line, the smell of freshly grilled burgers and golden fries wafted through the air, hinting at the magic awaiting me.

After some deliberation, I landed on their famous milkshake. Let me tell you: it didn’t disappoint. The shake's creamy texture was the stuff of dreams—smooth and rich, with just the right balance of sweetness. I opted for the chocolate flavor, which was indulgently thick, and my taste buds erupted with joy.

As I savored every sip, I was impressed by the genuine customer service; even during peak hours, the staff radiated warmth and professionalism, making it evident they care about the experience they provide. Whether you're stopping by after a late-night adventure or just looking for a solid shake, Dick's Drive-In is a must-visit for anyone yearning for that perfect indulgence in the heart of Seattle. Grab your shake—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Seattle.

Shake Shack University Village

Highlights
Best food among locations
Fresh and hot sandwiches
Neat and clean tables
Lively atmosphere
Exciting burger options

Shake Shack University Village has quickly become one of my favorite spots in Seattle for a multitude of reasons, not just their delightful shakes. Upon stepping through the doors, you’re embraced by a lively atmosphere that invites you to indulge. The clean and neat tables showcase the establishment's commitment to hygiene, making it a pleasant place to enjoy your meal.

I couldn't help but get drawn in by their exciting burger options, perfectly paired with the star of the show – the shakes. With each sip of the velvety chocolate shake, I found a balance between rich flavors and creamy textures that danced on my palate. It was utterly divine. The best food among locations was evident as I savored each bite of my freshly prepared sandwich, complementing the shake beautifully.

What I appreciate most is their dedication to serving everything hot and fresh. It’s clear that Shake Shack University Village is not just a place to grab a quick bite; it’s an experience that combines delightful flavors with a vibrant setting. If you’re in Seattle and yearning for the ultimate shake experience, don’t miss out on this gem!

You might also want to check out the best steak in Seattle.

Great State Burger

Highlights
Affordable under $10
Clean and well-maintained
Quick service at kiosks
Chocolate malt shake
Outdoor seating available

Nestled in the heart of Seattle, Great State Burger has quickly become a favorite of mine, particularly for their irresistible shakes. As I approached the bustling kiosk, the allure of their affordable menu (most items under $10) drew me in. The cleanliness and maintenance of the space immediately impressed me, making me feel right at home.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the chocolate malt shake. This delightful concoction struck the perfect balance between creamy and rich, elevating the traditional shake into something truly memorable. With every sip, I tasted nostalgia intertwined with a modern twist—pure bliss in a cup!

What I also appreciated was the quick service. The efficiency of the staff meant I didn’t have to wait long before indulging in my treat. And if the weather cooperates, the outdoor seating adds a nice touch, allowing you to savor your shake while soaking up the vibrant Seattle atmosphere.

Overall, my visit to Great State Burger was a delightful experience, and if you're on the hunt for a top-notch shake in Seattle, this spot should undoubtedly be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best sandwiches in Seattle.

Lil Woody's

Highlights
Fresh and flavorful shakes
Tasty burgers with good fixins
Cozy dining atmosphere
Plenty of fries included
Great view while dining

When it comes to finding the ultimate shake in Seattle, Lil Woody's is a delightful stop on the list. As I stepped into this cozy establishment, I was instantly enveloped by the aroma of hearty burgers and the warmth of friendly chatter. The decor feels inviting, making it easy to enjoy a leisurely meal while indulging in one of their signature shakes.

Now, let’s talk about the shakes—oh, what a treat! Each sip bursting with fresh and flavorful goodness, I opted for the classic vanilla, and it transported me to sweet, creamy bliss. And let’s not forget the accompanying heaping plate of fries—crunchy, golden perfection that makes you feel like you’re snagging the best of both worlds.

But the experience isn’t just about the shakes. The view from my seat was a bonus, a lovely slice of Seattle life. If you’re on a quest for the best shake in the city, Lil Woody's is a destination that should not be missed. So, grab a friend, enjoy the atmosphere, and prepare to savor one of the most delectable shakes around!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Port Angeles.

Burger Madness Seattle

Highlights
Magnificent burger layering
Yummy, non-processed beef
Perfect chocolate shake
Great customer service
Not too oily fish and chips

Burger Madness Seattle is a delightful treasure tucked away in the bustling cityscape, inviting all who crave a satisfying meal paired with a shake that dreams are made of. As I stepped into this vibrant eatery, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of their magnificent burger layering, each sandwich meticulously crafted to appeal to even the most discerning palate. Their beef boasts a yummy, non-processed quality that speaks volumes about their commitment to freshness.

Now, let’s talk shakes! I indulged in their perfect chocolate shake, an absolute treat that was not only rich and creamy but also held a nostalgic charm, transporting me back to my childhood. Sipping on this concoction while savoring my meal made for a heavenly combination.

But it isn’t just the food that shines — the great customer service truly sets this place apart. Each staff member exuded warmth and enthusiasm, enhancing the dining experience. My plate of fish and chips was pleasantly crisp and not too oily, complementing my shake beautifully.

In a city bustling with culinary choices, Burger Madness Seattle stands out, making it an essential stop for anyone searching for both great burgers and exceptional shakes.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Seattle.

206 Burger Co. ( FIRST HILL )

Highlights
Quick and delicious lunch
Lots of tasty options
Fresh and crisp veggies
Perfect brioche bun
Crunchy tater tots

The moment I stepped into 206 Burger Co. (FIRST HILL), I felt the buzz of an environment that screams casual cool. This burger joint isn’t just about juicy patties; their shakes are a delightful revelation. I ordered the classic vanilla shake, and let’s just say it was a smooth ride to flavor town! The creamy texture was a perfect match for the crispy tater tots, making my lunch a delightful adventure in taste.

What I truly appreciated was the freshness of the ingredients, from the salad greens to the fluffy brioche bun cradling my burger. Every bite was a symphony of flavor, and the veggies were a crisp contrast to the richness of the shake. It’s clear they prioritize quality, serving up many tasty options that cater to various palates.

The best part? I felt like a kid again with my shake in hand, savoring that sweet nostalgia amidst the modern vibe. 206 Burger Co. has officially earned a spot on my list of best shakes in Seattle. Do yourself a favor and treat that sweet tooth; you won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Seattle.

Molly Moon's Homemade Ice Cream

Highlights
Unique vegan flavor options
Fun seasonal flavors
Locally sourced ingredients
Compostable packaging
Cool merchandise

Review of Molly Moon's Homemade Ice Cream

When I stepped into Molly Moon's Homemade Ice Cream, I was greeted by an explosion of colors and whimsical decor that instantly put me in a good mood. Their shakes are nothing short of spectacular, and I couldn't wait to indulge in one! I opted for the blueberry lavender shake, a delightful combination that danced on my taste buds. The creaminess was reminiscent of childhood summers, while the unique flavor pairing elevated it to a whole new level of deliciousness.

What truly impressed me was the commitment to sustainability. All their packaging is compostable, making me feel good about indulging in such a decadent treat. And let’s not forget about the vegan options! They craft shakes that cater to all kinds of diets, ensuring there’s something for everyone. I tried their vegan chocolate shake, and it was rich, satisfying, and left me wanting more.

With seasonal offerings that keep the menu fresh, every visit promises something new. If you find yourself wandering through Seattle, make a beeline for Molly Moon's; it’s a delightful shake stop that embodies the very essence of homemade goodness!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Silverdale.

Milk Drunk

Highlights
Best Fried Chicken & Soft Serve
Earthy Matcha Flavor
Tart Cherry Soft Serve
Fun Chocolate Hard Shell
Delicious Vanilla/Chocolate Twist

Review of Milk Drunk in Seattle

When I stepped into Milk Drunk, I was greeted by a whimsical vibe that instantly set the stage for a fantastic shake experience. Their standout offerings go beyond the ordinary! I couldn’t resist trying their fried chicken and soft serve combo, a perfect pairing of savory and sweet that had me grinning ear to ear.

The earthy matcha flavor was a delightful surprise, weaving a rich narrative in every sip. I also had to dabble in the tart cherry soft serve, which sang with a refreshing tang that playfully danced on my taste buds. And let’s not forget the fun of their chocolate hard shell—it was a spectacular textural contrast that left me wanting more.

As I indulged in a delightful vanilla and chocolate twist, I couldn’t help but appreciate how this little gem of a shop has elevated the shake game in Seattle. If you’re on the hunt for an adventurous shake experience, Milk Drunk is a must-visit destination. Their quirky combinations will certainly leave a lasting impression on your palate! ✨

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Tacoma.