Seattle's Best New York Style Pizza [Updated 2025]

Having reviewed twelve standout pizzerias across the city, I’ve tasted each slice with a discerning palate, searching for that perfect balance of crispy crust, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese.

Seattle’s pizza scene is more diverse than ever, but the charm of classic New York-style pizza still holds a special place in my heart.

From bustling Pike Place Market to the cozy corners of Ballard, I’ve uncovered hidden gems and popular favorites alike that redefine what it means to enjoy a slice.

Join me as I dive into the best spots where you can savor authentic New York-style pizza right here in the Emerald City!

Post Alley Pizza

Highlights
Perfect substitute for NYC
Tucked away in an alley
Divine Italian hoagie
Solid pepperoni slice
Unique blend of traditional taste

Post Alley Pizza Review

Tucked away in a charming alley, Post Alley Pizza immediately invites you in with the aroma of freshly baked dough. As soon as I stepped inside, I was transported to the bustling streets of New York City, where the pizza slices are an art form. The pepperoni slice I ordered was not just solid in flavor; it was an outstanding melody of spices with a satisfying crunch. Each bite seemed to sing a chorus of deliciousness that had me reminiscing about my favorite NYC pizzerias.

But what truly caught my attention was their divine Italian hoagie—an excellent complement to my pizza feast. Packed with flavor, it offered a taste experience that was as layered as the city itself. I couldn't resist grabbing a slice of their pepperoni pizza before heading out, and it did not disappoint. The crust was just the right blend of crispy and chewy, embodying the essence of a classic New York slice.

In the whirlwind of pizza options in Seattle, Post Alley Pizza stands out as a delightful recommendation. If you're craving that unmistakable taste of New York, this hidden gem is a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Tacoma.

Nine Pies Pizzeria

Highlights
Fresh, high-quality ingredients
Thin, crispy crust perfection
Excellent, friendly service
Great for pizza and wine pairing
Impressive for New York fans

Nine Pies Pizzeria is a delightful gem that takes you straight to the bustling streets of New York with every bite! Upon entering, I was welcomed by the friendly staff, who genuinely seemed to love their craft. This pizzeria doesn’t just serve pizza; it delivers an experience.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the pizza! The thin, crispy crust is nothing short of a revelation. It’s the perfect canvas—a harmonious blend of crunch and chewiness. The toppings? Absolutely delectable! You can taste the fresh, high-quality ingredients with each slice, which gave my tastebuds a reason to celebrate.

If you’re a fellow New York fan, you’ll appreciate the authenticity they bring to the table, ensuring each pie is crafted with precision and passion. I also loved the option to pair my pizza with a selection of wines, making it a great spot for casual dining or a fun night out.

In a city bustling with pizza options, Nine Pies holds its own and deserves a cherished spot on your must-visit list for an unforgettable slice! Trust me when I say, you won’t walk away disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best boba in Seattle.

Johnny Mo's Pizzeria

Highlights
Good garlic breadsticks
Too greasy for some
Incorrect vegetarian labeling
Mixed reviews on authenticity
Overall good pizza experience

Johnny Mo's Pizzeria is a little slice of New York nestled in Seattle, and stepping inside, you’re greeted by the comforting familiarity of a classic pizzeria. I couldn’t resist starting with their garlic breadsticks, which arrived freshly baked, golden, and slightly crispy. They were the perfect companion while I awaited my pizza.

I opted for a classic cheese slice, and while the flavor was undeniably good, I noticed it leaned a bit on the greasy side, which some might find overwhelming. It wasn’t quite what you’d expect if you were looking for that quintessential NY slice—there were moments when I thought the grease could start a small oil spill! Additionally, I was surprised by some vegetarian labeling on the menu that didn’t quite align with what I received, leaving me scratching my head.

Despite a few hiccups, the pizza was an overall enjoyable experience. In a city that’s not always known for authentic NY-style fare, Johnny Mo's offers a nice attempt. While opinions may vary about how well they replicate the New York vibe, it’s a fun stop for those craving that classic pizzeria atmosphere with a twist!

You might also want to check out the best hamburgers in Tacoma.

Serious Pie Downtown

Highlights
Best thin-crust pizza
Fresh and flavorful ingredients
Phenomenal pizza and ambience
Top-notch and polite service
Not greasy, perfectly baked

Serious Pie Downtown caught my attention the moment I stepped in with its inviting ambiance and the tantalizing aroma of fresh dough in the air. As a connoisseur of New York style pizza, I was eager to dive into their thin-crust offerings. My first bite was an absolute delight—the crust was not only perfectly baked, but it also provided a satisfying crunch that set the stage for the fresh and flavorful toppings.

The pizza managed to strike that delicate balance of being light and crisp without feeling greasy, which is often a pitfall for many. I couldn’t help but appreciate how the quality of ingredients was apparent in every mouthful. The service was another highlight; the staff was top-notch, attentive, and radiated a warmth that made me feel like a regular, even on my first visit.

In a city renowned for its diverse culinary scene, Serious Pie Downtown has carved out a niche for itself with pizza that stands tall against even the best from the Big Apple. If you find yourself in Seattle and yearning for an authentic slice of New York-style pie, this place is truly a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Bellevue.

Humble Pie

Highlights
Unique outdoor seating
Fresh, thin crust pizza
Street parking available
Casual, family-friendly vibe
Happy Hour pizza discounts

Humble Pie: A Slice of New York in Seattle

During my recent pizza pilgrimage, Humble Pie stood out as a hidden gem that I simply couldn't overlook. Set in a cozy neighborhood, this place boasts unique outdoor seating that invites you to bask in the fresh Seattle air while indulging in your favorite slice. Their thin, fresh crust pizza offers that ideal combination of crispy and chewy, taking me back to my favorite NYC haunts with every bite.

What I loved most is their casual, family-friendly vibe—it's the kind of place where you might stumble upon a birthday celebration or a group of friends just unwinding after a long day. And let's talk about their Happy Hour pizza discounts! Who doesn’t love a great deal while enjoying a delicious slice?

Finding street parking nearby was the cherry on top of an already delightful experience. Overall, at Humble Pie, you're not just getting a meal; you're enjoying a piece of the New York pizza culture, all while sitting in the heart of Seattle. It’s a must-visit for anyone who appreciates a well-crafted pizza in a relaxed atmosphere!

You might also want to check out the best chocolate in Seattle.

Alibi Room

Highlights
Exceptional service
Great happy hour deals
Delicious cheesecake dessert
Located near Gum Wall
Quick bite options available

Alibi Room Review

Nestled just a stone's throw from the famous Gum Wall, Alibi Room captures the spirit of New York with every slice. As I stepped inside, I was greeted by exceptional service that felt warm and inviting, setting the stage for what would be a delightful journey through pizza paradise.

What caught my attention immediately were the great happy hour deals—who can resist a fantastic slice at a fantastic price? I opted for their classic New York-style pie, with its thin crust and delightful toppings. Each bite danced with flavor, truly capturing that familiar New York essence.

To cap my meal, I indulged in their delicious cheesecake dessert, an outstanding way to end a pizza adventure. Quick bite options are also available for those on the go, making it a perfect stop for locals and visitors alike.

In my quest for the best New York-style pizza in Seattle, Alibi Room stands out—not just for its delectable offerings but also for its vibrant atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. If you’re looking for a slice of New York in Seattle, Alibi Room is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in South Seattle.

ROCCO'S

Highlights
Great bar seating
Huge pizza slices
Beautiful speakeasy decor
Delicious veggie pizza
Extensive alcohol selection

ROCCO'S in Seattle is a delightful nod to the Big Apple's iconic pizza joints, and I can’t help but appreciate the atmosphere as soon as I walk in. The beautiful speakeasy decor wraps you in charm, making it a spot you want to linger in, especially while you enjoy the impressive bar seating.

Now, let's talk pizza. The slices here are huge, and each bite is a perfect blend of chewy crust and vibrant toppings. I sampled their delicious veggie pizza, and the fresh ingredients truly shine through. It reminded me of the classic slices you’d find on a bustling NYC street corner, yet it’s nestled right here in the heart of Seattle.

What also caught my attention was their extensive alcohol selection—a great companion to a fantastic meal. In a city where pizza can often feel reinvented, ROCCO'S remains true to the roots of New York style, marrying tradition with a local twist. If you're craving that authentic pizza experience, look no further—grab a slice (or two) at ROCCO'S and indulge yourself in pizza perfection.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Tacoma Waterfront.

Hot Mama's Pizza

Highlights
Exceptional flavor profiles
Crunchy bottom crust
Fresh, high-quality ingredients
Consistent quality slices
Great for whole pizzas

Hot Mama's Pizza effortlessly transports you straight to the bustling streets of New York with every delectable slice. The first thing I noticed upon entering was the exceptional flavor profiles that danced on my palate— each ingredient in perfect harmony, hinting at care and quality.

The crunchy bottom crust was a revelation! Not flimsy, but sturdy enough to support the generous toppings without sacrificing the coveted foldability that any worthy New York slice demands. Speaking of toppings, the use of fresh, high-quality ingredients truly shines through, making you appreciate where each flavor comes from.

And let’s talk consistency; every slice I sampled maintained that same delightful experience, showcasing the consistent quality that’s rare to find these days. Whether you’re ordering a whole pizza for a gathering or just treating yourself to a slice, this spot quickly becomes your go-to.

If you're searching for a slice that encapsulates the spirit of New York while basking in the vibrant culture of Seattle, Hot Mama's is undeniably a must-visit. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Bellevue.

Big Mario's Pizza

Highlights
Perfectly cooked pizza crust
Dive-bar vibe with great drinks
Big NY-style pizza slices
Inexpensive and filling meals
Rotating special flavor options

Big Mario's Pizza immediately caught my attention with its laid-back dive-bar vibe—think mismatched furniture and local art adorning the walls. As soon as I stepped in, I knew I was in for a treat. Their NY-style pizza slices are the real deal; you can practically hear the crust singing from the oven! Perfectly cooked to achieve that glorious, crisp exterior while maintaining a chewy interior, every bite was an ode to the classic pizzerias of New York.

One of the highlights for me was their rotating special flavor options, which kept my taste buds on their toes amid my quest for the best slice. I opted for the pepperoni explosion, and boy, did it deliver! The flavors were bold and fell just right with every mouthful, complementing the crust beautifully.

And let’s talk about value—each slice is not just generous in size; it's also wonderfully inexpensive and oh-so-filling. With a drink in hand and a slice of heaven on my plate, I can confidently declare that Big Mario's is a standout gem for any pizza lover in Seattle. Whether you're a local or visiting, don’t miss this slice of paradise!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Bellevue.

Italian Family Pizza

Highlights
Affordable lunch specials
Large pizza slices
Perfect sauce to cheese ratio
Quick service
Chewy crust

When I stepped into Italian Family Pizza, the aroma of baking dough engulfed me like a warm hug on a chilly Seattle day. The first thing that caught my eye was the affordable lunch specials—my wallet appreciated this as much as my stomach! I opted for a large slice, which arrived looking beautiful: the dough perfectly golden, the cheese bubbling just right.

As I took my first bite, I was met with a divine sauce to cheese ratio that danced on my taste buds. The flavors melded seamlessly, each slice a testament to traditional New York style pizza-making—delicious without overwhelming. The chewy crust was a dream; it had the right amount of bite while maintaining its structural integrity even under the weight of generous toppings.

I must say, the service was impressively quick, ensuring that my craving was satisfied without a lengthy wait. In a bustling city, Italian Family Pizza stands out, delivering a slice of New York straight to the heart of Seattle. If you're on the hunt for pizza that hits all the right notes, this spot is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Everett.

Numero Uno Pizza

Highlights
Exceptional service overall
Fantastic pizza and salads
Delicious garlic-seasoned crust
Accommodating to personal preferences
Great cheese and pepperoni selection

Numero Uno Pizza truly lives up to its name, standing out in the crowded Seattle pizza scene. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by the exceptional service overall—the staff was warm and inviting, setting the perfect tone for my culinary adventure.

Now, let’s talk about the real star of the show: the pizza itself. I opted for their classic pepperoni slice, which was a harmonious blend of crispiness and gooey perfection. The garlic-seasoned crust was a delightful surprise, adding a layer of flavor that danced on my palate with every bite.

Moreover, I appreciated how accommodating they were with personal preferences—my requests were met with enthusiasm, which assures me that every guest's experience is both personal and unique.

The fantastic pizza and salads made for a mouthwatering combo that was hard to resist. In my opinion, they’ve nailed the quintessential New York style: the perfect balance of cheese and toppings, with a generous sprinkle of love. If you're on the hunt for the best slice in Seattle, Numero Uno Pizza deserves a top spot on your must-try list!

South Town Pie

Highlights
Friendly and courteous staff
Flavorful toppings
Ideal for late-night cravings
Best enjoyed fresh
Thick crust not for everyone

South Town Pie is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Seattle, and my taste buds are still dancing from the experience! As I entered, the friendly and courteous staff immediately made me feel welcome, setting the tone for what would be a splendid night of pizza indulgence.

When it comes to the flavorful toppings, South Town Pie does not shy away from creativity. I opted for their house special, and let me tell you—each bite was an explosion of flavors, perfectly blended to achieve that quintessential New York taste.

As someone who often craves late-night munchies, I was thrilled to discover that this spot has some late hours. And make sure to enjoy your pizza fresh out of the oven—the contrast of that slightly chewy, thick crust with the gooey cheese and toppings was a revelation! However, I should note that the crust might not appeal to everyone, especially if you lean towards a thinner bite.

If you're in Seattle and have a passion for New York-style pizza, don't miss out on South Town Pie—where every slice whispers secrets of the city that never sleeps!