The Absolute Best Pizza in Bainbridge Island [Updated 2025]

Having sampled an incredible range of pizzas from 12 local establishments, I’ve honed in on what makes a truly great slice.

From flavorful crusts to fresh toppings, each pizza offers a unique experience that captures the essence of Bainbridge Island’s culinary scene.

Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or adventurous combinations, there’s something here for everyone.

Join me as we explore these delicious options and uncover the hidden gems of our vibrant island, where each bite tells a story.

Treehouse Cafe

Highlights
Friendly and efficient service
Spacious seating options
Good food despite busy hours
High prices, reasonable value
Inconvenient takeout pizza boxes

Treehouse Cafe is a delightful gem tucked away in Bainbridge Island, where I recently indulged my pizza cravings. As soon as I stepped into the spacious seating area, I was greeted by smiles from the staff, showcasing their friendly and efficient service. In no time, I found myself seated and perusing their menu, which is overflowing with tasty options.

What truly surprised me was the quality of their pizza, even during bustling hours. My choice was the classic margherita, and let me tell you, the balance of flavors was delightful. Yes, the prices are on the higher side, but considering the impeccable ingredients and generous portions, I felt it was reasonable value for such deliciousness.

One minor hiccup was related to takeout—the boxes can be a bit inconvenient, making transport tricky. However, I quickly forgave this little faux pas when a slice of their cheesy goodness graced my palate. Overall, Treehouse Cafe offers a fantastic pizza experience, making it a must-visit on Bainbridge Island. I’ll definitely be returning to savor more of their mouthwatering offerings!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Seattle.

Bainbridge Brewing

Highlights
Friendly and attentive staff
Superb drink selection
Scenic and comfortable location
Perfect for relaxing outings
Nearby pizza place

Bainbridge Brewing is a delightful gem tucked away on Bainbridge Island, where the aroma of freshly brewed beer melds exquisitely with the scent of bubbling pizza. From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted by friendly and attentive staff who made me feel at home. The scenic and comfortable location offers the perfect backdrop for a laid-back outing with friends or a romantic evening.

As I perused their menu, I couldn't resist trying their selection of craft beers, which pairs beautifully with their mouthwatering pizzas. Every bite of my pizza was a celebration of flavors, with a crispy yet chewy crust that truly stood out. It's no wonder that this spot is perfect for relaxing outings—the atmosphere practically invites you to linger a bit longer, sipping beer and savoring every last slice.

What I found particularly charming about Bainbridge Brewing is how close it is to nearby pizza places, making it an ideal stop before or after indulging in a full meal. If you're in the mood for a playful yet professional dining experience, I wholeheartedly recommend checking out Bainbridge Brewing. It’s a pizza lover’s paradise!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Seattle.

Agate Restaurant

Highlights
Warm and inviting atmosphere
Delicious food options
Attentive and friendly service
Great for special occasions
Excellent appetizers

Exploring the sunny shores of Bainbridge Island, I found myself beckoned by the warm and inviting atmosphere of Agate Restaurant. Right from the moment I stepped inside, the ambiance felt like a warm hug—perfect for a foodie adventure!

I decided to dive into their pizza offerings, and let me tell you, the flavors danced on my palate. The crust was perfectly crisp yet delightfully chewy—a true testament to their artisanal approach. The toppings were fresh and generously applied, elevating each slice to a savory masterpiece.

Beyond the pizza, their appetizers whetted my appetite splendidly, enhancing the entire experience. It’s clear that Agate isn’t just a place to grab a slice; it’s a culinary destination ideal for special occasions.

The staff was particularly attentive and friendly, ensuring my dining experience was seamless and enjoyable. It's not just about filling your stomach; it's about the warmth of the service mingling with the delicious food options that make your meal memorable.

All in all, Agate Restaurant is one of the best spots for pizza on Bainbridge Island—a place where every bite feels like a celebration! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best steak in Seattle.

Harbour Public House

Highlights
Great views and ambiance
Excellent chowders
Comfortable outdoor seating
Well-priced drinks
Friendly and attentive service

Harbour Public House is simply a must-visit for any pizza lover touring Bainbridge Island. Nestled by the waterfront, it offers breathtaking views that make every bite of pizza feel like a slice of paradise. As I settled into the comfortable outdoor seating, I couldn’t help but appreciate the charming ambiance of this locale—it’s the perfect backdrop for a laid-back meal.

Now, onto the pizza! I ordered the signature pub pie, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The crust was a perfect balance of chewy and crisp, holding up well to a delightful array of toppings. Each bite was bursting with flavor, and I quickly found myself smiling like a kid in a candy store.

To complement my pizza, I couldn't resist trying one of their famous chowders. It was rich and creamy, making it a perfect appetizer. The friendly service throughout my visit made the experience even more enjoyable, and I appreciated the well-priced drinks that accompanied my meal.

If you’re on the hunt for great pizza with a side of scenic waterfront views, Harbour Public House definitely delivers!

You might also want to check out the best sandwiches in Seattle.

Nirvana Indian & Nepali Cuisine

Highlights
Delicious mango curry
Friendly and attentive service
Great vegan options available
Crunchy baby corn Manchurian
Highly recommended eggplant bharta

While Nirvana Indian & Nepali Cuisine is renowned for its delectable offerings, it might not be the first place that pops into your mind for pizza. But during my visit, something unexpected happened. While they serve ** sumptuous mango curry** and heavenly baby corn Manchurian, my mind drifted to the creativity of fusion.

The service here is nothing short of attentive and friendly, which sets a cozy mood for a delightful dining experience. Yet, amidst the aroma of spices, I couldn't help but envision what a unique pizza crafted with Indian and Nepali flavors might taste like. Imagine a naan-inspired crust topped with tandoori chicken, vibrant vegetables, and perhaps a drizzle of mango chutney!

Nirvana also shines with its vegan options, making it a fantastic spot for those seeking plant-based delights. The eggplant bharta captivated my tastebuds, highlighting the restaurant's artistry.

Though Nirvana may not have the best pizza on Bainbridge Island, its culinary diversity and passionate service make it worth a visit for an entirely different kind of comfort food experience. And who knows? Maybe one day, they'll surprise us with their take on pizza!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Port Angeles.

Jake's Pickup

Highlights
Gas station gem
Superb egg Sammy
Exceptional customer service
Must-try cinnamon sconut
Delicious hot dog sandwich

Jake's Pickup is truly a hidden gem nestled within the unassuming walls of a gas station. At first glance, you might not expect to find an extraordinary pizza experience here, but that’s where the magic happens! The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with exceptional customer service that made me feel right at home.

I decided to indulge my curiosity and ordered a classic pepperoni pizza. The crust was perfectly crispy and golden, while the toppings were fresh and generous. Each bite was a delightful orchestra of flavor that left me smiling. But what's a pizza review without mentioning the other culinary stars? The egg Sammy was superb, a comforting, hearty addition to any breakfast, and I couldn't resist sneaking a taste of the signature cinnamon sconut, which was just the right amount of sweet and spice.

Lastly, if you’re up for a twist, don’t overlook the delicious hot dog sandwich – it's a crowd-pleaser! All in all, Jake’s Pickup may surprise you like it did me; pizza perfection truly resides wherever passion meets creativity!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Seattle.

Sunny Hill

Highlights
Best pizza in Seattle
Friendly and welcoming staff
High quality ingredients
Excellent salad options
Detroit style pizza

Sunny Hill Review

Nestled in the heart of Bainbridge Island, Sunny Hill serves up a slice of pizza perfection that quite literally brightens the day! Known for having some of the best pizza in Seattle, this charming eatery has quickly carved out a niche for itself in the local culinary scene.

As I stepped inside, I was warmly greeted by the friendly and welcoming staff, who certainly know how to make guests feel at home. With a menu that showcases high-quality ingredients, my anticipation began to build. I opted for their renowned Detroit style pizza, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The crust was an irresistible blend of crispy and chewy, topped with vibrant, fresh ingredients that danced on my palate.

But don't overlook their excellent salad options—Sunny Hill truly believes in the balance of flavor. Each dish complements the other, ensuring a truly delightful dining experience. With its inviting atmosphere and top-notch pizzas, Sunny Hill is genuinely a gem on Bainbridge Island. If you’re in the area, it's a must-visit for anyone who appreciates the artistry of great pizza!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Seattle.

Damn Fine Pizza

Highlights
Great vegan pizza options
Friendly and helpful staff
Efficient ordering system
Delicious "bomb" pizza
Enjoyable music ambiance

When I wandered into Damn Fine Pizza on Bainbridge Island, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere and friendly faces that immediately set the tone for a delightful dining experience. As someone who appreciates a good slice, I was thrilled to discover their variety of vegan options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a hearty meal.

The ordering process was efficient, and the upbeat music in the background made the ambiance feel quite lively. I decided to try their signature "bomb" pizza, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The flavors danced on my palate, and each bite burst with freshness. The crust was beautifully crispy, and the toppings were generously applied.

The staff was incredibly helpful, providing recommendations based on my preferences, which only enhanced my experience. It's that kind of warmth that makes a place feel like home. If you’re looking for a pizza joint that combines delicious food with a welcoming spirit, Damn Fine Pizza is a definite must-visit. Give it a shot—you'll be glad you did!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Silverdale.

The Plate & Pint

Highlights
Warm and welcoming atmosphere
Creative weekend specials
Thoughtful and attentive service
Local favorite for islanders
Standout menu items available

The Plate & Pint is an absolute gem and a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts on Bainbridge Island. From the moment I stepped inside, the warm and welcoming atmosphere wrapped around me like a cozy blanket. This local favorite beautifully blends comfort with creativity, evident in their creative weekend specials that keep even the seasoned foodies on their toes.

As I scanned the menu, I was thrilled by the promise of standout items that reflect the island's vibrant culinary scene. When my pizza arrived, it was a spectacular sight—golden crust with toppings that looked like a work of art. Each bite was a delightful crescendo of flavors, courtesy of the thoughtful ingredients chosen by the kitchen.

The service was stellar; my server was not only attentive but genuinely passionate about every dish. It's clear that The Plate & Pint has carved a special niche for itself among islanders. Whether you’re looking for a casual dinner or a fun night out, this place delivers on all fronts. I left with a happy belly and a new favorite pizza spot, eagerly anticipating my next visit. If you haven’t experienced it yet, you're truly missing out!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Tacoma.

Bruciato

Highlights
Fluffy wood-fired dough
Exceptional Tiramisu dessert
Courteous and attentive staff
Vibrant date night atmosphere
Great cocktail selection

Bruciato – A Slice of Heaven

Stepping into Bruciato feels like entering a cozy, culinary haven where the scent of wood-fired dough tantalizes the senses. As I settled in, I couldn’t help but admire the vibrant atmosphere—a perfect backdrop for a romantic date or a fun night out with friends. The staff greeted me with warmth, demonstrating their commitment to exceptional service with every interaction.

The star of the show was undoubtedly the pizza. Each slice revealed a fluffy crust, baked to perfection, with just the right amount of char that adds depth to every bite. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, harmoniously combining together to create a symphony of taste. There’s nothing quite like indulging in this wholesome creation while sipping on a delightful cocktail from their impressive menu.

But don’t make the mistake of skipping dessert! I indulged in their tiramisu, which was a heavenly finish to my meal. Creamy, rich, and beautifully balanced, it was the perfect way to wrap up a wonderful dining experience. If you find yourself on Bainbridge Island, make it a point to visit Bruciato—you won’t be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best steak house in Seattle.

Via Rosa 11

Highlights
Authentic Italian cuisine
Top-tier customer service
Cozy atmosphere
Fresh wood-fired pizza
Knowledgeable staff

When I stepped into Via Rosa 11, I was immediately enveloped in a cozy atmosphere that felt like a warm Italian embrace. The aroma of wood-fired pizza dancing in the air was enough to make any food lover’s heart skip a beat. This charming spot serves up authentic Italian cuisine, and trust me, they don’t skimp on character or flavor!

Their menu offered a delightful selection of fresh ingredients, crafted into pizzas that boast a crust crisped to perfection. I indulged in a classic Margherita, and every bite sang with the freshness of ripe tomatoes and basil, rocking the flavor scale with a hint of smokiness from their wood-fired oven. It's evident that they prioritize quality, from their dough to the toppings.

What truly sets Via Rosa 11 apart is their top-tier customer service. The staff was not only knowledgeable but genuinely passionate about the dishes being served. They shared insights about the local sourcing of ingredients, enhancing my overall dining experience.

If you’re on Bainbridge Island and craving pizza with a generous side of charm, Via Rosa 11 is a place you'll want to savor—it's a slice of heaven! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Bellevue.

That's A Some Pizza

Highlights
Excellent pizza quality
Friendly, attentive customer service
Quick food preparation
Outdoor dining experience
Great for groups and picnics

When I stepped into That's A Some Pizza, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough wrapped around me like a comfortable hug. Instantly, I was intrigued by the excellent pizza quality, which boasts a perfectly crisp crust and vibrant toppings that sing with flavor. The friendly and attentive customer service added a personal touch, making me feel like part of the family from the get-go.

I couldn’t resist ordering their signature pie, and as I eagerly anticipated my meal, I appreciated the swift preparation. Within moments, a steaming pizza was placed in front of me, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The balance of fresh ingredients and an expertly crafted sauce danced on my palate, leaving me almost speechless.

Another delightful feature of That's A Some Pizza is the outdoor dining experience—perfect for soaking in Bainbridge Island's charm while enjoying a slice. Ideal for groups or a laid-back picnic, this spot captures the essence of community. As I finished my meal, I realized that this pizzeria stands out not only for its scrumptious offerings but also for the atmosphere it creates. If you're on the hunt for a top-notch pizza experience, That's A Some Pizza should definitely be on your radar! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best boba in Seattle.