West Seattle's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

With 12 local pizzerias reviewed, I've tasted everything from classic Margheritas to unique artisanal creations. Each bite has taken me on a delicious journey through our vibrant community.

West Seattle is a treasure trove of pizza options, reflecting the diverse flavors and culinary creativity of our neighborhood.

Join me as I share my top picks, highlighting the standout pies that deserve a spot on your table.

Whether you’re a lifelong resident or just visiting, you're bound to find a new favorite in this collection. Let's dig in!

Talarico's Pizzeria West Seattle

Highlights
Giant pizza slices
Creative topping options
Lively atmosphere
Excellent value
Great service

At Talarico's Pizzeria West Seattle, you’re in for a delightful surprise with their giant pizza slices that are sure to satisfy even the heartiest of appetites. The moment I walked in, the lively atmosphere wrapped around me like a comforting blanket, punctuated by laughter and the delightful scent of freshly baked pizza.

One of the standout aspects of Talarico's is their creative topping options. I opted for the house special, adorned with a medley of flavors that danced across my taste buds—each bite more delightful than the last. What truly impressed me was the excellent value for the quality offered; you genuinely feel like you’re getting your money’s worth here, and with slices as large as these, you won’t leave hungry.

Adding to the experience was the great service that left me feeling welcomed and appreciated. The staff members were attentive and eager to share recommendations. Talarico's isn't just about pizza; it's an experience that combines taste, atmosphere, and exceptional hospitality. If you're on the hunt for the best pizza in West Seattle, don’t miss the chance to indulge in this gem!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Downtown Seattle.

Il Nido

Highlights
House-made pastas
Exceptional service
Best burrata dish
Delicious pistachio cheesecake
Unique seasonal specials

Il Nido is truly a gem tucked away in West Seattle, making it a delightful stop for anyone craving pizza with a twist. From the moment I walked in, the exceptional service made me feel right at home. The ambiance is warm and inviting, perfect for a cozy dinner.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the pizza! Their creative toppings paired with house-made pastas create a delightful culinary experience. I indulged in a seasonal special that featured unique ingredients I had never imagined could work so harmoniously together. Each bite was a revelation, bursting with flavors that danced on my palate.

And while you're there, you absolutely cannot miss their best burrata dish—a creamy, rich delight that complements the pizzas perfectly. To cap off the meal, I savored the delicious pistachio cheesecake, which added a sweet finish to my adventure.

Il Nido is an example of how pizza can transcend the ordinary. Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure this culinary treasure is on your list. West Seattle's pizza scene certainly shines bright with Il Nido leading the charge!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Bellevue.

West of Chicago Pizza Company

Highlights
Authentic Chicago Deep Dish
Welcoming and Friendly Service
Variety of Pizza Styles
Jones Cane Sugar Soda on Tap
Charming Family-Owned Atmosphere

Review of West of Chicago Pizza Company

When I stepped into West of Chicago Pizza Company, I was instantly greeted by the welcoming aroma of freshly baked pizza that seemed to embrace me like an old friend. Being a fan of authentic Chicago deep-dish, I knew I was in for a treat. Their thick, flaky crust cradled generous layers of rich, tangy tomato sauce and gooey cheese, effortlessly hitting the right notes of comfort and indulgence.

Each bite was a delightful revelation, with a medley of toppings that showcased their commitment to quality and flavor. What truly stood out was not just the pizza itself, but the friendly service that made me feel right at home. Staff members shared stories of their family traditions around pizza, adding an intimate touch to the dining experience.

To elevate this pizza adventure even further, I paired my slice with a refreshing Jones Cane Sugar Soda on tap—an unexpected yet fantastic compliment. The charming, family-owned atmosphere made every moment enjoyable, solidifying their rightful place among the best pizza joints in West Seattle. If you’re craving a slice of Chicago charm, this spot is an absolute must-try!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Tacoma.

Peel & Press

Highlights
Gluten-free pizza options
Fluffy yet crunchy crust
Friendly and attentive service
Generous cheese portions
Inviting ambiance

Visiting Peel & Press in West Seattle was a delightful adventure that exceeded my expectations. The moment I stepped inside, the inviting ambiance wrapped around me like a warm hug. The staff was not only friendly but genuinely attentive, ensuring my dining experience was top-notch.

Now, let's talk about the pizza! I opted for a classic pepperoni, and I was thrilled with the fluffy yet crunchy crust that boasted a perfect golden-brown hue. One bite revealed a generous portion of gooey cheese, each slice pulling away in delicious strings—pure pizza bliss! I also appreciated their commitment to accommodating all dietary preferences, as they offer gluten-free options that are just as satisfying as the original.

What struck me most was the overall balance of flavors. The sauce was zesty and just the right amount of tangy, complementing the savory toppings beautifully. It's clear that Peel & Press has mastered the art of pizza-making.

If you're searching for a slice of pizza heaven in West Seattle, look no further. Peel & Press sets the bar high and is sure to leave you craving more!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Port Townsend.

GH Pasta and Pizza

Highlights
Chill and classy atmosphere
Fresh and delicious pasta
Crowd-favorite pizza
Friendly and helpful staff
Great for special dinners

My recent visit to GH Pasta and Pizza was an absolute delight! From the moment I stepped inside, I was enamored by the chill and classy atmosphere; it struck the perfect balance between cozy and sophisticated. The ambient lighting set the stage for a lovely evening. As I perused the menu, I couldn't resist the temptation of their freshly made pasta – but let's be honest, I was here for the pizza!

As soon as the crowd-favorite pizza arrived, it was a symphony for the senses. The crust was impeccably baked, delivering just the right balance of crispness and chewiness. Topped with high-quality ingredients, each bite was a tantalizing journey through flavors. The tangy sauce complemented the abundant cheese, creating a mouthwatering fusion.

But what truly stands out at GH is the character of the establishment. The friendly and helpful staff exuded enthusiasm for their craft, making every patron feel welcomed. This gem is perfect for a special dinner or a casual slice with friends. If you’re seeking pizza that’s not just food but an experience, look no further than GH Pasta and Pizza. It’s a slice of heaven in West Seattle!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Seattle.

Sopranos Antico Pizza & Pasta

Highlights
Best Italian restaurant
Amazing garlic bread
Off-the-charts pizza
Friendly service
Lovely atmosphere

When it comes to pizza in West Seattle, Sopranos Antico Pizza & Pasta has firmly placed its name in the spotlight. This gem transcends the typical Italian dining experience, making it my go-to for a delightful evening out. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a wonderfully warm atmosphere that felt just like a cozy Italian trattoria.

Now let’s talk pizza—off-the-charts delicious. The crust was artfully crafted; crisp on the outside yet perfectly chewy on the inside. Topped with fresh ingredients that sang with flavor, each slice felt like a well-balanced work of art. I would also be remiss if I didn’t mention their amazing garlic bread—it's the perfect starter before diving into their mouthwatering pies.

What truly stood out was the friendly service; the staff made me feel right at home and eager to please. If you're seeking the best of what West Seattle has to offer, look no further than Sopranos. With great food and a lovely atmosphere, this place should be at the top of your pizza list! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Seattle.

La Rustica

Highlights
Incredible gnocchi
Fresh Italian sausage
Friendly staff
Fantastic location
Amazing focaccia

La Rustica captured my heart—and my taste buds—during my latest West Seattle pizza adventure. Nestled in a fantastic location, the atmosphere buzzes with a warmth that makes you feel instantly at home. As I approached the rustic facade, I was greeted by the friendly staff, whose welcoming smiles suggested I was in for a treat.

Now, onto the pizza! I ordered their signature dish, and the first bite was like a delicious revelation. The crust was perfectly baked, offering that crunchy exterior with a soft, airy interior. The toppings were fresh, especially the Italian sausage, which brought a flavorful zing that delighted my palate. Each slice brimmed with vibrant ingredients harmonizing beautifully for a truly memorable experience.

But the culinary wonders didn’t stop there; I couldn’t resist trying the incredible gnocchi. Each pillowy bite was simply divine! And let's not forget about the amazing focaccia—a perfect companion that made my pizza adventure even more enjoyable.

Overall, La Rustica redefines pizza in West Seattle with its exquisite cuisine and warm ambiance. If you're in the area, this gem is undoubtedly worth a visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best burger in Seattle.

Dantini Pizza

Highlights
Vegan Pizza lacks flavor
Tiny yet cozy corner shop
Amazing thin crust
Located inside a whiskey bar
Tasty menu with limited options

When I stumbled upon Dantini Pizza, tucked inside a cozy whiskey bar, I felt like I had found a hidden gem. The atmosphere was delightful—tiny but inviting, creating a unique vibe that encourages both casual munching and relaxed sipping. As I scanned the menu, I noted the options were limited, yet everything seemed thoughtfully crafted.

I decided to try their much-lauded thin crust pizza. Oh, let me tell you, the moment I took my first bite, I was transported! The crust was a perfect balance of crispy and chewy—definitely not something you find just anywhere. However, my experience took an unexpected turn when I ventured into their vegan pizza option. Unfortunately, it was a tad underwhelming and lacked the vibrant flavors I had hoped for.

Despite this minor setback, Dantini Pizza still holds its own in the bustling pizza scene of West Seattle. It's a charming spot for those looking to pair their slice with a fine whiskey, making it a worthy stop for anyone on a quest for pizza perfection. So, if you find yourself nearby, don’t miss this delightful little corner shop! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Seattle.

Proletariat Pizza

Highlights
Best pizza in Seattle
Affordable daily slices
Incredible staff and service
Huge, high-quality pies
Family-friendly atmosphere

Proletariat Pizza is an absolute gem in West Seattle, championing the art of pizza with gusto and flair. From the moment I stepped inside, the vibrant atmosphere enveloped me, making it feel like the perfect spot for any pizza enthusiast. The staff greeted me with warm smiles, setting the tone for an enjoyable visit.

Now, let's talk about the pizza—the real star of the show! Proletariat serves what I believe to be some of the best pies in Seattle. Each slice is a masterpiece, boasting huge portions that are both delicious and filling. I savored a classic margherita, which showcased a delicate balance of fresh basil, tangy tomato, and creamy mozzarella. The crust? Perfection! It's airy yet sturdy enough to support the generous toppings.

One of the highlights of my experience was the affordability of the daily slices, making it accessible for families and pizza lovers alike. Proletariat Pizza strikes a lovely balance between quality and value, ensuring that each visit brings joy to the table. If you’re in West Seattle and on the lookout for pizza that delights, this spot is an absolute must-try!

You might also want to check out the best steak in Seattle.

Raccolto

Highlights
Good cocktail and wine menu
Solid service
Nice ambience
Delicious duck dish
Great dessert options

Nestled in the heart of West Seattle, Raccolto is a true gem for pizza lovers like myself. Upon walking in, I was immediately struck by the charming ambience; it’s the kind of place that invites you to linger over dinner. The cocktail and wine menu is impressive, providing the perfect pairing for your meal.

I opted for a classic pie and was blown away by the rich flavors. Each bite was a delightful blend of fresh ingredients, cooked to perfection. As a bonus, the solid service ensured my glass was never empty, making for an all-around enjoyable evening.

And let’s not forget the non-pizza options: the duck dish was a real standout, offering an equally delightful experience for those not in the mood for a slice. To top it all off, I couldn't resist the tempting dessert options. Trust me, there's always room for dessert, especially when it's this good!

Raccolto is more than just a pizza joint; it’s a culinary experience. If you're in West Seattle and craving a slice (or two), this place should definitely be on your radar!

You might also want to check out the best eats in Seattle.

Christos On Alki

Highlights
Spectacular pizza
Delicious Greek sampler
Inviting staff and atmosphere
Great outdoor seating
Perfectly balanced toppings

Christos On Alki is an absolute gem tucked away along the beautiful Alki Beach. The moment I stepped inside, the inviting atmosphere wrapped around me, making me feel right at home. The charming staff greeted me with warm smiles, setting the tone for what was to come—an Italian culinary adventure!

Now, let’s talk about the pizza! I opted for their signature pie, and let me tell you, it was a spectacular delight. The crust was perfectly baked—crisp, yet delightfully chewy. Each bite delivered a harmonious balance of toppings, dancing on the palate with each exquisite flavor.

To accompany my pizza, I indulged in their delicious Greek sampler, which seamlessly complemented my meal with its fresh, zesty notes. And if you’re fortunate enough to snag a seat outside, the view of the beach is a bonus spectacle—perfect for savoring your food while soaking up the sun.

In summary, Christos On Alki isn’t just about great pizza; it’s about the entire experience, making it one of my top picks for pizza in West Seattle. I’ll be dreaming of my next visit!

You might also want to check out the best pho in Seattle.

MOTO Pizza West Seattle

Highlights
Unique pizza flavor combinations
Casual and welcoming ambiance
Exciting clam chowdah pizza
Options for vegan preferences
Slightly pricey for portions

MOTO Pizza West Seattle quickly stole my heart (and appetite) during my culinary quest for the best pizza in the area. From the moment I stepped into this cozy haven, I was greeted by a welcoming ambiance that felt like a blend of rustic charm and contemporary style.

What sets MOTO apart is its unique pizza flavor combinations that tickle the taste buds in the most delightful way. I simply had to try their clam chowdah pizza, an inventive take on two beloved dishes that left me craving more with every buttery, garlicky bite. The balance of flavors was superb; it felt like a warm embrace on a chilly Seattle day.

For my fellow pizza lovers with dietary restrictions, MOTO also offers options that cater to vegan preferences, ensuring that everyone can indulge in a slice of happiness. Although I found the prices on the higher side for portion sizes, the quality of ingredients and creativity on the menu certainly justifies the investment.

In a city teeming with pizza joints, MOTO Pizza West Seattle stands out with its artistic flair and mouthwatering offerings. If you find yourself in West Seattle, be sure to add this gem to your pizza pilgrimage! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best sandwiches in Seattle.